How to Navigate Family Drama During the Holidays Without Losing Your Mind
Episode 30: Behind the Therapy Door
This article draws on a conversation between therapists Sarah Thome and Matt Gallagher. Listen to the full episode for the stories behind the takeaways.
The holidays are supposed to be magical. Instead, you are sitting at a table with relatives who hold opposing political views, a parent who critiques everything, a sibling who still treats you like you are twelve, and a simmering argument about whose turn it is to host that has been going on since 2019. On Episode 30 of Behind the Therapy Door, the Season 1 finale, Sarah Thome and Matt Gallagher tackle the unique emotional minefield of holiday family conflict, from boundary-setting and grief to the liberating truth that creating your own traditions is not a betrayal of your family. It is a sign of growth.
Related: Understanding communication patterns.
Related: PCM® personality types.
Why Is Creating Your Own Holiday Traditions a Sign of Healthy Development?
Many people feel guilty when they want to change holiday routines. Skipping the big family dinner, starting a new tradition with your own partner and kids, or choosing not to travel feels like a rejection of the family you came from. Sarah reframes this entirely: creating your own traditions is a developmental milestone. It means you have differentiated enough from your family of origin to build a life that reflects who you are now, not just who they raised you to be.
This is especially difficult for the sandwich generation: adults caring for aging parents while raising their own children. The pull in both directions is constant. Your parents want the traditions they have always had. Your children want the traditions you are building. You are in the middle, trying to honor both while slowly losing yourself. Sarah’s advice is direct: you are allowed to choose your own well-being without it being an act of betrayal.
Related: PCM® workshop for parents.
Related: Families.
How Does PCM® Explain Why Holiday Family Conflict Pushes Your Buttons?
Your family of origin is the original testing ground for your PCM® patterns. The distress sequences you learned at that table are the ones you default to under holiday stress. Matt describes catching himself in Thinker distress before a gathering, unable to wind down, “vibrating,” and quick to apologize for it. Persister energy, meanwhile, can leave you pretty sure you already know the right way to do things. Recognizing which pattern is driving you is what lets you step out of it instead of acting it out at the table.
Blood is thicker than water,
Sarah Thome, Behind the Therapy Door
Sarah shares a story about her 103-year-old grandmother, a character who loves a little attention and plays the organ so loudly during Christmas dinner that nobody can carry on a conversation. Was it frustrating? Maybe. But she is a hoot, and the family adores her for it. Understanding the PCM® type behind a behavior does not make it less annoying. But it does make it less personal.
Related: PCM® vs MBTI.
Related: PCM® vs Enneagram.
What Is the Best Way to Handle Contentious Topics at Family Gatherings?
Sarah offers a phrase that is disarmingly simple and remarkably effective: “I love you too much to talk about that contentious topic.” That sentence does three things at once. It affirms the relationship. It names the boundary. And it refuses the invitation to fight without dismissing the other person. Most boundary-setting advice sounds clinical: “I need to set a boundary around this topic.” Sarah’s version sounds like love, which is why it actually works in a family context where clinical language gets rejected.
The thank-you note debate from this episode illustrates how small things become proxy wars. Should you send thank-you notes? Should you require your children to? On this one Sarah and Matt actually agree: both see the obligatory thank-you note as something that can turn a gift into a debt rather than a simple thank-you. Even so, in many families these small-stakes questions touch core values: gratitude, social norms, generational expectations, and what counts as basic politeness versus performative obligation. These debates are really about whose values get to govern the shared space. The thank-you note is never just a thank-you note.
Related: Couples communication workshop.
Related: About Sarah and Matt.
How Do You Navigate Holiday Grief When Someone Is Missing From the Table?
Holiday grief is a category of pain that people rarely talk about openly. The empty chair. The recipe nobody makes anymore. The ornament that belonged to someone who is gone. Sarah shares her own experience of losing her father and the rituals that help: wearing his flannel shirt, drinking coffee on an Ozark bluff where they used to sit together, holding space for the sadness without trying to fix it or rush past it.
Blue Christmas church events provide a structured space for this grief during the holiday season, services specifically designed for people who are mourning while the rest of the world is celebrating. Sarah recommends them as a counterweight to the relentless pressure to be joyful. Not every holiday moment needs to be happy. Some need to be honest. And as Donna Lewis writes in her poem “Take Me With You,” the people we have lost travel with us whether we acknowledge it or not. Acknowledging it is simply choosing to carry them in the light instead of the shadows.
Sarah calls National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation the best Christmas movie ever, a movie that endures because it tells the truth about holiday family dysfunction wrapped in comedy. Clark Griswold’s desperate pursuit of the perfect Christmas is every person who has ever tried to manufacture joy through sheer force of will. The movie works because audiences recognize themselves in the chaos. The “perfect holiday” is a myth. The real holiday is messy, imperfect, and held together by people who keep showing up despite all of it.
Related: Best communication assessment.
Related: PCM® profile assessment.
What Does “Blood Is Thicker Than Water” Really Mean for Modern Families?
The phrase is typically used to shame people into prioritizing biological family above all else. Sarah challenges this directly. Chosen family is real family. The people who show up consistently, who support your growth, who hold space for your grief; they are your family regardless of DNA. As Sarah frames it, some people live by “Blood is thicker than water,” while others say, “Friends are the family you choose,” and the family who actually shows up for you is the one that counts.
This reframe is especially important during the holidays when obligation masquerades as connection. You are not required to endure toxic dynamics simply because you share a last name. You are allowed to build a holiday that includes the people who nourish you and to set boundaries with the people who deplete you. That is not abandoning family. That is protecting the version of family that actually works.
Related: Workshops and training.
Related: Contact us.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I set boundaries with family during the holidays?
Use language that affirms the relationship while naming the limit. Sarah’s phrase “I love you too much to talk about that contentious topic” works because it leads with warmth. Avoid clinical boundary-setting language with family members who will hear it as rejection. The goal is to protect the relationship and your peace simultaneously.
Is it okay to skip family holiday gatherings?
Yes. Creating your own holiday traditions is a sign of healthy development, not a betrayal. If attending a gathering consistently leaves you depleted, resentful, or emotionally unsafe, choosing an alternative is a valid and mature decision. You can love your family and still choose not to attend every event they host.
How do I handle holiday grief when everyone else is celebrating?
Give yourself permission to feel the loss without performing joy. Rituals help: wearing a loved one’s clothing, visiting a meaningful place, or attending a Blue Christmas service designed for people who are grieving during the holidays. You do not have to choose between honoring your grief and participating in celebration. Both can coexist.
Why do small disagreements become huge fights during the holidays?
Holiday stress activates PCM® distress patterns that amplify small conflicts. Sleep deprivation, financial pressure, and proximity to family members who trigger old patterns create a combustible environment. Small disagreements become proxy wars for deeper issues about whose values govern the shared space and whose traditions take priority.
What does “chosen family” mean and is it valid?
Chosen family refers to the people you select as your inner circle based on mutual support, shared values, and consistent presence rather than biological connection. It is fully valid. Some people live by “Blood is thicker than water,” but many find that “Friends are the family you choose,” the people who show up consistently are family in every way that matters.
Reach the Kid You Actually Have.
Navigate family dynamics with confidence. Join our next parent workshop.